Deborah McFarlane All articles
Personal Essay

Before the Spotlight Finds You: What the Lean Years Are Actually Teaching You

Deborah McFarlane
Before the Spotlight Finds You: What the Lean Years Are Actually Teaching You

Every creative career has a highlight reel. The breakthrough role. The sold-out show. The moment someone with a platform finally says your name out loud. Those are the stories that get told at panels, plastered across bios, and recycled in interviews until they're practically mythology.

What doesn't get talked about nearly as much? The three, five, sometimes ten years before any of that happened.

I've been thinking a lot lately about how we talk — or don't talk — about the unglamorous middle. That stretch of time between starting out and actually getting somewhere. The years of driving two hours for a twenty-minute set. Of refreshing your email after an audition and hearing nothing. Of picking up a side job and telling yourself it's temporary while secretly wondering if it's actually permanent.

Here's what I want to say about all of that: it's not filler. It's the foundation.

The Mythology of the Overnight Success

American culture is obsessed with the launch story. We love a good origin moment — the open mic that changed everything, the viral clip that came out of nowhere, the agent who spotted you at the exact right time. And look, those moments are real and they're worth celebrating.

But they're almost never the whole story. What gets edited out is the decade of low-stakes, low-audience, low-pay work that quietly built the person who was ready for that moment when it finally arrived.

The struggling years don't make for a clean narrative. They're full of contradictions — you're simultaneously getting better and feeling worse about yourself. You're learning, but nobody's watching. You're putting in the work, but the results are invisible. That's a hard place to live, and it's even harder to frame as meaningful while you're inside it.

But here's the thing: that invisibility is part of what makes it so valuable.

When Nobody's Watching, You Find Out What You Actually Have

Performing for a nearly empty room strips away every external motivation. There's no crowd energy to feed off of, no applause to reassure you, no validation loop to keep you going. What you're left with is the raw question: do I actually want to do this, or do I just want the version of this where people already care?

That's not a comfortable question. But it's one of the most important ones a creative person can answer honestly.

The small gigs — the open mics, the community theater productions, the local storytelling nights where half the audience is there because their friend guilted them into coming — those are where you build your real relationship with your craft. Not the performance of your craft. Not the brand version of your craft. The actual, unpolished, figuring-it-out-in-real-time version.

You learn what works when the room isn't already on your side. You learn how to recover from a joke that lands wrong, a technical glitch, a moment where you completely lose your train of thought. You learn how to read silence and adjust on the fly. That's not something you can fast-track. It accumulates slowly, through repetition, through failure, through showing up anyway.

Rejection Is a Weird Kind of Mentorship

I used to keep a mental tally of every no I received. Every audition that led nowhere. Every pitch that got ignored. Every collaboration that fell apart before it started. At a certain point, the list got long enough that I had to make a choice about what I believed it meant.

Option one: the rejections were evidence that I wasn't cut out for this.

Option two: the rejections were data, and I could learn something from each one if I was willing to look.

I won't pretend I always chose option two. Some days, I absolutely chose option one and spent the evening convinced I should have gone into something more practical. But over time — and I mean years of time — I started to notice patterns. I started to see which kinds of projects I kept getting cut from and why. I started to understand the difference between rejection that was about fit and rejection that was about something I genuinely needed to work on.

That kind of self-awareness doesn't come from success. It comes from losing enough times that you're forced to pay attention.

The Financial Instability Nobody Wants to Admit

Let's be honest about something that creative career narratives almost always skip over: the money part is genuinely hard, and it takes a real psychological toll.

Working a day job while trying to build a creative career isn't a character flaw or a sign that you're not committed enough. For most people, it's just the reality of how this works. And there's a particular kind of exhaustion that comes from splitting your energy — giving your best hours to a job that pays the bills while trying to save enough creative energy for the work that actually matters to you.

What I've come to believe is that navigating that tension builds something important: resourcefulness. When you don't have a budget, you get creative with what you have. When you don't have connections, you learn how to make them from scratch. When you can't afford the fancy equipment or the professional recording space, you figure out what's actually essential and what's just nice to have.

Some of the most inventive, distinctive creative work I've ever encountered came from people who were working with almost nothing. Constraints, it turns out, are a surprisingly good teacher.

What You Carry Forward

There's a version of success that makes artists fragile. The ones who arrive with too much support too soon — who never had to figure out how to hold a room that didn't already like them, who never had to rebuild after a project tanked, who never had to sit with uncertainty long enough to get comfortable there. When things get hard, and they always eventually do, those artists sometimes don't have the internal resources to weather it.

The struggling years build those resources. Not because suffering is inherently noble — it isn't — but because working through difficulty, over and over, in low-stakes environments, gives you a kind of confidence that external validation never can. You know what you're made of because you've already tested it.

You've bombed and recovered. You've been overlooked and kept going anyway. You've done the work when the work felt pointless, and you've come out the other side still wanting to do it.

That's not nothing. That's actually everything.

So If You're In the Middle Right Now

If you're somewhere in that unglamorous stretch — grinding through the small gigs, sitting with the rejections, wondering when the turning point is coming — I'm not going to tell you it's easy or that it'll all make sense soon. I don't know your timeline and I'm not going to pretend otherwise.

What I will say is this: the version of you that exists on the other side of this season will be built from exactly what you're doing right now. The patience, the resilience, the willingness to keep showing up when the results aren't there yet — that's not wasted time. That's your real education.

And honestly? It's one nobody can take away from you.

All Articles

Related Articles

When One Role Tries to Own You: The Messy, Honest Truth About Reinventing Yourself in Entertainment

When One Role Tries to Own You: The Messy, Honest Truth About Reinventing Yourself in Entertainment

What Happens When the Plan Falls Apart (And Why That's Actually the Good Part)

What Happens When the Plan Falls Apart (And Why That's Actually the Good Part)

The Project That Bombed and the Best Thing It Ever Did for Me

The Project That Bombed and the Best Thing It Ever Did for Me